The Transition to Medicare Podcast
Moving yourself into the Medicare system for the first time can be a challenge. When we say "first time" we mean those folks that are turning 65 and need Medicare now or those that are retiring past age 65 and have to figure out how to go from their employer sponsored insurance and over to the Medicare system. That's where we come in. Join Joanne Giardini-Russell and Cameron Giardini along the with rest of the "Transition to Medicare Team" as they get you there in the right way. Our Michigan-based insurance agency can coach you through the process and enroll you into the products that you need to pair up with your Medicare. You can call us at 248-871-7756. Or, visit our website at www.gmedicareteam.com. And, please check out our free Medicare course at www.gmedcourse.com We provide Medicare products to those in the following states: MI -- AZ, CA, FL, IL, IN, MD, NC, OH, PA, SC, TX
The Transition to Medicare Podcast
How are Medicare Brokers Actually Paid?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Are you curious about how Medicare brokers earn their living and how this may impact you, the consumer? In this enlightening episode, we pull back the curtain on the commission structures for selling Medicare products, shedding light on the often-misunderstood world of Medicare commissions.
We unravel how brokers are paid, from selling Medicare Advantage and Medigap plans to hidden incentives that add to their earnings. Learn the distinction between initial and renewal plans and how commission rates differ for various products. Get an in-depth understanding of the Medicare Advantage and Medigap commission structures, backed by real-world examples and precise calculations. We'll also compare these two plans to see which is more lucrative for brokers.
Additionally, we'll expose the hidden incentives, including new carrier bonuses, underwritten bonuses, and reward trips, and discuss how they affect a broker's decision and earnings. Join us as we debunk the mysteries of this industry, fostering transparency for Medicare beneficiaries.
Giardini Medicare is an independent insurance agency specializing in helping Medicare beneficiaries enroll in the Medigap or Medicare Advantage plan that fits their needs during their transition to Medicare. We are licensed and work virtually in the following states: AZ, CA, FL, IL, IN, KY, MI, MD, NC, OH, PA, SC, TX If we do NOT work in your state, we can refer to agents that we know, like & trust across the country. Fill out the form linked to our map.
Check out our website at https://gmedicareteam.com/
Also, see our additional educational content over on our YouTube Channel
You can also connect with and learn more on TikTok and our private Facebook Group and while you're at it, check out our Google Reviews! And please get added to our mailing list so we can remain in touch with you.
Sources:
Senator Warren Hidden Incentives Report
CMS Broker Compensation Data
More Broker Commission Data
Agent Commission Impacting Consumer Choices
Example of Medicare Broker Incentive Reward Trips
Joanne:
With all the advertisements and phone calls that you receive daily from people trying to sell you Medicare products, it might be obvious that there is money to be made in the Medicare space, but how do insurance agents get paid when they're selling Medicare supplements?
Is one option more lucrative than the other? We're going to break down all of that and more in today’s episode
Cameron:
But before we start, my name is Cameron Giardini. Together with my co-host Joanne Giardini Russell, we operate Giardini Medicare, an independent insurance agency based out of Southeast Michigan.
And although we are based in Michigan, we do work virtually over the phone to directly help consumers in about 13 states to find the right Medicare coverage for them. Of course, if we do not work in your state, we will connect you with another trusted, independent agent that will be able to help you find the right coverage that you want.
And even if you choose not to work with us, we know that the information in today's podcast will help you with a successful and stress-free transition to Medicare. So, a quick overview of this episode. We will talk about the basics of how Medicare brokers are paid. We are only going to be talking about independent brokers, not employees that work for insurance companies, or maybe even other employees that work for companies selling plans like brokers.
But this is truly for independent brokers like us, how we typically get commissions based on the products that we offer. And we will go into more detail specifically about Medicare Advantage versus Medicare supplement commissions. Just remember, we usually call Medicare supplements Medigap plans. So, we will use the term Medigap for the rest of this episode, and we will talk about which of those options might pay a broker more.
Does one of them even pay more? Then lastly, we will talk about hidden incentives for Medicare Advantage and Medigap plans, which include incentive trips, overrides, bonuses, a lot of things that many consumers are not aware of. Now, a quick note, if you have not already listened to our episodes about the basics of Medicare or the differences between Medigap, And Medicare Advantage plans.
We highly recommend listening to that before this episode, or a lot of the concepts that we talk about will seem confusing. Now that we got that out of the way, I'll have Joanne start by talking about the basics of how Medicare brokers are paid.
Joanne:
All right. So, people that we talk to often are asking us, how do you get paid?
Today we're going to shed some light on that question, and we're going to break down exactly how we make money as independent brokers. Now we're discussing this today for transparency’s sake, not for bragging. Okay, so what is a broker? A broker is someone that is essentially an independent contractor that contracts with dozens of insurance companies typically to sell their Medicare products.
We must get appointed with each carrier that we offer, and that we represent, and we have to complete training and certifications in order to be able to sell their plans. Brokers are paid commissions from the insurance company when we enroll a client into one of their plans. The insurance company does not charge you, the consumer any extra money for your premiums if you use a broker and you get the exact same product as you would if you were calling the insurance company directly.
Brokers will typically offer many products such as Medigap, Medicare Advantage, dental and Vision, life insurance, health insurance, cancer insurance, and more products. All brokers can typically offer the exact same products as one another, so what becomes a differentiator is knowledge and service, for example.
If you ever feel that you're being oversold a product, just so a Medicare broker can make more commission, just ask them why are recommending the products that you're doing. We do receive different commissions for Medicare Advantage versus Medigap plans. So, we're going to talk about exactly how we're paid for each of those products so that at the end of the day, there's no mystery for you, the consumer.
Cameron:
Yeah. And again, just to highlight what Joanne said, this episode, it's not for agents. It's not for brokers to understand more about how they're paid. It's really to shed some light to you, the consumer, to figure out, okay, what's going on behind the scenes? When somebody's recommending this plan to me, is there a hidden incentive?
What are they getting paid? Is there just an ulterior motive as to why they're recommending what they do? Everyone always thinks. You know, commissions create a bias. So, the whole point of this episode is just transparency, so you can better understand what it looks like on our end as far as how we get paid.
With that out of the way, let's talk about Medicare Advantage commissions. We often say that Medicare Advantage plans and Medigap plans are fundamentally different products, and the same is true for the commission they provide to brokers like ourselves.
So, although most Medicare Advantage plans offer plans with zero monthly premiums, they still provide plenty of commissions to the brokers that sell them. These commissions are paid by the insurance companies, and they are set by CMS, which is the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and they come out with these new commission standards pretty much every year.
They do tend to increase slightly over time, but they are set by CMS. Now Medicare Advantage plans, they have different commissions for initial and renewal plans. So those are the two keywords here. An initial commission is paid when an agent enrolls a consumer, somebody like yourself for the first time in a Medicare Advantage plan.
While a renewal commission is paid to agents, every year you stay enrolled in a plan or if you stay enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan with that broker. This also includes if you change from one Medicare Advantage plan to another Medicare Advantage plan with that broker.
But again, it just must not be your first time in that plan for them to receive renewal commissions. So, for 2023, in most states, the initial Medicare Advantage Commissions $601 per year with a renewal commission of. $301 per year. However, this can be as high as $750 per year initially, and $375 per year as a renewal in California and New Jersey for example.
These commission levels, they're true for Medicare Advantage plans with zero premiums or even plans that have higher premiums that could range to a couple of hundred dollars per month. It does not matter what the Medicare Advantage Premium is. Again, you get these set commissions based on what CMS guidelines are each year.
And each company pretty much pays these maximum commissions, so you're not swayed to offer one Medicare Advantage plan over the other. Now, just a quick example to kind of wrap that up. If we help you transition to Medicare and we enroll you in a Medicare Advantage plan for the very first time, and it's your first time in a Medicare Advantage plan, we will receive a first-year commission of $601, and then every year, you remain on a Medicare Advantage plan as our client going forward, we will get a renewal commission of $301 per each of those years. I know that was a lot, but again, we already talked about Medigap commissions being very different from Medicare Advantage Commissions. So now Joanne can talk about how they are different
Joanne:
And just a warning, this is a lot too. So, just prepare
Cameron:
Yes. So, it's transparent, but it's also. Kind of complex, with all the detail, but a lot of little numbers and nuances
Joanne:
We're going to shift over like Cameron said to Medigap commissions. Again, they're typically much different than Medicare Advantage plans since they're not set by CMS, okay?
They're typically going to be instead related to the premiums that you pay for your Medigap plan. Medigap commissions just understand they can vary greatly. But we're going to talk about common realistic numbers in this example. So, let's start with Michigan. If you buy a plan through Company A, they're going to pay 29% commission to an agent like us for years one through three, then it's going to drop down to four and a half percent commission from years four onward. And that's for a Medigap plan G. So, this means that with that company, whatever you pay in a monthly premium, your broker's going to receive 29% of that amount as a commission during the first three years that you're on the plan.
Cameron:
So, just a quick example of that. Like Joanne was saying, it's 29% of your premiums that you pay. So, if you have a $100 per month premium for your Plan G, essentially, the broker would get $29 or 29% of that as a commission per month.
Now you're not paying them $29 directly. It's all done on the back end, but that's how it works out
Joanne:
Exactly. Now let's look at company B. So instead of paying a percentage of the premium as a commission, they instead will pay a fixed amount of $400 for years one through three. It drops down to $265 per year commission to the agent from years four through six. And then in years 7 to 11, it drops down further to $133 a year.
Cameron:
Just going back to our example, if you have one hundred dollars per month premium, this one does not care about your premium, and we just get paid that $400 year one through three regardless
Joanne:
There you go. So, if you buy a Medigap plan, it's very likely that you're going to also purchase a Part D prescription standalone drug plan.
This plan also provides a commission to brokers, but like a Medicare Advantage plan, this part is set by CMS, and in 2023, an initial, which means new to Medicare, Part D commission is typically $92 a year for the initial plan and is a $46 a year for renewal plans after that. So, all that's summing up a quick example here.
If we help you transition to Medicare and you enroll into Plan G with company A with a monthly premium of $135 a month annual premium of 6,000, and an annual premium of $1,620 a year, we will get a commission of $470 for that year if you also enrolled in a Part D plan. For the first time, that would result in a total commission of $562 for that first year.
Cameron:
Yep. Exactly. And those are very realistic numbers, especially for us in Michigan when it comes to premiums and commissions for a Medigap Plan G. So, the question you may be wondering is, do Medicare Advantage plans pay agents more than Medigap? You might have heard this. Medicare brokers get paid more to sell Medicare Advantage plans.
So, is that true? Well, based on the examples that we just gave, a new Medicare Advantage Plan Commission would pay us $601. Versus a Plan G, also with a Part D plan, that would give us a commission of $562 for that same year, so case closed, right? Medicare Advantage Plans, they just pay more than Medigap, and the only reason agents sell Medicare Advantage plans is their greedy, right?
Well, of course, that's not the case. There are many factors that go into the differences in commissions with these plans, and there are many reasons why you would sell one or the other, or really you should be offering both. But I'll keep breaking down these differences, so keep in mind that. In this example, we just assumed that you never had a Medicare Advantage plan.
So that commission was an initial one of $601. So, what if you have already had a Medicare Advantage plan and now you're going to a new broker like ourselves to enroll in a different Medicare Advantage plan? Well, then suddenly, your premium is a renewal one. Then all of a sudden, our commission is a renewal one that drops down to $301.
That makes a huge difference. And all of a sudden, the Medigap plan pays us more. So now is it the opposite again; there's never going to be one scenario where one always makes you more than the other. But we will save you some of the added details here. We can share these calculations if you want. Feel free to email us.
We'll link a lot of stuff in these show notes as far as sources. But if you winna know how we calculated these, just email us at info@gmedicareteam.com. But if you're brand new to Medicare, as a consumer and a broker like ourselves enrolls you in a Medicare Advantage plan, we calculated that if you stay on that plan or if you stay with an Advantage plan for six years, your broker will earn $2,350 in commission during that six-year period.
Now instead, let's say you enrolled in Plan G when you were first starting out, and that is with company A using the numbers Joanne already talked about. And let's say you also add a Part D plan. Now, during those same exact six years, your broker with the Medigap and the Part D would earn $2,200.
So, if you're comparing the two, that means over a six-year period there is only a roughly $150 commission difference or a difference of $25 per year when you're comparing an average Medicare Advantage plan versus an average plan g plus part D coverage. Now $25 per year. Yes, it can add up a lot with thousands of clients, but when you're really looking at it on a case-by-case basis, I truly don't believe that's going to sway a broker to offer one versus the other.
Now, keep in mind that in these calculations, we also considered that the commissions for Medicare Advantage plan raise over time, as well as the premiums for Medigap plans raise over time so that increases commission. So, we took all of that into account when we're doing these numbers.
But the most important thing you should know as a consumer is that overall, the single biggest factor that earns brokers the most commissions is having a client for a long time. The longer you stay in a plan, the longer we get paid. We already talked about those renewal commissions. So, this, I think, makes it a win-win for the broker and the consumer.
So, to maximize commissions, we really must keep you with good coverage for a long period of time. And I would assume, you know, as a consumer, you also want to have good coverage for as long as possible. Now, I don't want you to think that you must stay with the exact same plan if possible.
That doesn't really matter to us. If you go through six different Medicare Advantage plans, we're still getting those renewal commissions. So if you are using our services as a broker, even if you're changing plans, we just want you to be in the right coverage for as long as possible, and that will yield way more commissions to us versus getting you in one plan versus the other just for one year.
But what about hidden Medigap incentives that you might not hear about as a consumer that are more on the backend, that most agents are aware of, but most don't really share? I'll have Joanne talk about that.
Joanne:
Senator Elizabeth Warren made a report called “Sales before Seniors, how Medigap Insurers sales rewards hurt seniors on Medicare”. This was published back in February of 2023. It quotes private Medigap insurance companies offering luxurious vacations and cash bonuses to agents and brokers, creating incentives for them to steer seniors to Medigap products that may not be the best fit for their financial and healthcare needs.
In 2021, 6 million seniors purchased a Medigap plan from an insurance company that did offer an incentive trip, and as of 2022, there were 32 companies providing cash bonuses and vacations as incentives to brokers, which they say may be an underestimation due to the lack of publicly available information.
The main concern here, of course, is that agents will sell plans based on bonuses, trip credits, et cetera, even if the plan isn't the right fit for the consumer, which can cost them, in the long term, the consumer. Also, agents’ incentive trips are not regulated by CMS. A 2013 analysis cited in the report found that most consumers don't choose the cheapest Medigap plan, which is not bad.
Cameron
We'll talk about it; again, this is just talking about what is in the report. We'll give our thoughts about it after. So just to continue with what the report shed some light on. Senator Warren also says that brokers qualify for incentive trips based on meetings, and sales thresholds based on the consumer's plan premium, which we already talked about earlier in our examples.
But the report says that this may create an incentive to push consumers into more expensive plans, which might not even have as good of coverage. So, for example, they talk about a Plan K in Florida, which is on the market for $1038 per year, which has a higher premium but fewer benefits than Plan F, which they say has an $852 premium per year. So again, main takeaway, they're saying brokers will put you in a worse plan with a higher premium just to qualify for trips. Now, the report also mentions that some trip qualifications are based on persistency thresholds.
This means that a certain percentage of clients just needs to stay enrolled in the plan to qualify for a trip. And the report, just so you know, has a persistency rating. In the report, it says that companies require about a 70% persistency rating for a broker to qualify for a trip, and then this also says that this may encourage agents from recommending a client change to a new plan, even if that plan may be better for them.
Now, the report says agents may be more inclined to offer Plan F and Plan G, and they might not mention Plan N, which could be a good option for many consumers. But it comes at a lower premium, therefore making it worse for trip qualification. Now the report concluded the following, and it says, an agent or broker who is focused on selling enough of one company's Medigap products to earn their next vacation is an agent who is not focusing entirely on finding the best plan for an individual senior.
So again, that is everything that was highlighted in the report. I do want to just go over one quick concept. So, when we say higher premiums to qualify for a trip, usually a company will say, if you sell $200,000 of premium, we'll give you a trip to Aruba as an example. So that's why they're saying agents want to sell more expensive plans to get closer to that threshold, quicker to get their trip that they're looking for.
That's a good point. So now our thoughts. Yep. So, our thoughts on the report, Joanne can kick it off.
Joanne:
So overall, again, the report shed some light on monetary incentives for insurance brokers that most consumers are not aware of. Right. So, we believe the intent behind the report is good.
But the report itself really does miss many key details, so we're going to highlight those right now. First, is it true that Medicare insurance brokers can receive cash bonuses and paid vacations from Medigap insurance companies? Is that true? Of course, yes, it is. It's one hundred percent true, and it does happen very often.
We've been on them. We, yep. Cameron was on one recently. I was on one last year. So, we have been on those. 32 companies offering incentive trips is likely an overestimation, and it's not an underestimation, like the report claims. The reason for this is that many insurance companies have different subsidiaries that they count as different companies in this report that are offering the trips.
For example, they list five Aetna companies on the list when really all those Aetna companies offered the same trips. So, we looked at the 15 cheapest Medigap plans being offered in our local metro Detroit market for a 65-year-old. And as far as we know, of those in 15 insurance companies, seven do offer an incentive trip.
So, the 2013 analysis in the report said that most consumers don't choose the cheapest Medigap plans. And to that, we say that's good. That's a really good thing because, Medigap premiums increase over time, and this is typically even more true of the newer, smaller Medigap companies that start by offering the cheapest premiums out there on the market.
Brokers aren't offering slightly more expensive plans for vacation points, but instead, because the absolute cheapest plan may not be the right company long term for you. So, tune into the episode. You can tune into our episode about how Medigap premiums increase for more information about that.
The report mentioned a concern that agents may be focused on only selling Plan F and Plan G and not offering Plan N. So, we do agree with the report on this one. Brokers not presenting Plan N as a viable option are really doing a disservice to clients.
Cameron:
Yeah, exactly. Couldn't have said it better. And just to continue what our thoughts are on the report done by Senator Warren's office, I'm going to talk about what they had mentioned with the Plan K versus the Plan F.
The report claims that agents may try to sell Plan K, which really is not heavily sold at all because of the benefits. But again, they're saying in Florida at $1038 per year, and an agent would be more likely to sell that Plan K than a Plan F, which has more benefits at $852 per year just to add higher premiums and get to that trip qualification sooner.
So, the data for this one they're using, I'm not sure where they got it, but I'll just say it's fundamentally wrong. We ran a quote in Orlando, Florida, for the same 65-year-old female non-smoker that they use in the report, and we found Plan K would be about $742 per year compared to Plan F at $2,184 per year.
So, with that logic, Plan F would be the winner for the client and for the agent, right? When it comes to trip qualifications. The report also mentioned persistency. Basically, it just said that some trips require you to have more persistency or a higher persistency percentage. It's kind of a fancy term, but it just means that at least 70% of clients enrolled in a Medigap plan need to stay with that plan for a certain period for the broker to qualify for the trip.
70% persistency is very low, and most brokers putting people in the right coverage should have persistency in the high 90% range. Lower persistency means that consumers are changing plans in large numbers, and the only reason people would be more likely to change plans is that you're not in the right plan in the first place.
I think this is a good thing to require higher persistency. The company is saying to sell people good plans so they don't change. They don't want a bunch of agents writing junk plans just to get a trip, and then suddenly, they all start changing plans. So, this is a positive instead of a negative.
The conclusion of the report highlights everyone's main concern perfectly, and it says an agent or broker who is focused on selling enough of one company's Medigap product to earn their next vacation is an agent who is not focusing entirely on finding the best plan for an individual consumer. That's absolutely correct.
This may only happen with a very small number of agents, but we really don't believe it's true for most. Remember, we talked about providing the right coverage for our clients and keeping them happy long-term. It results in much more commissioned long-term and is worth way more than one incentive trip.
Also, keep in mind that these incentive trips, usually require agents. Sell about 150 Medigap plans just with one company, which is a lot of plans. So, the agents that are qualifying for these trips, really should be the better agents that have more experience, and they know better than to let a trip influence what they sell.
You're not going to find a brand-new agent that gets newly licensed, and they just go and sell one plan just to get vacations. It's not really that simple. it really doesn't work that way, ever.
Joanne:
And let me interject right there, though. So, the other thing that's not in our notes here is that we as agents, get taxed on the value of the trip.
So, at the end of the day, it’s not as much of a freebie as it kind of seems, and the trips could be structured sometimes where you've just with a bunch of agents, is that really one of where you want to be on vacation? You know, so there's, there's more to it behind the scenes.
Cameron:
They're nice trips, but yeah, we don't want to make it sound like they're lavish, extravagant things we do.
We pay taxes on the amount that the trip is worth. It's a very set period. It should say, do you want to go to Aruba with a bunch of other insurance agents? That headline's not as enticing as what it may seem. Right. Yeah. And we're not trying to complain about vacations.
Don't, don't take it that way, but it's interesting.
Another hidden incentive that applies to both Medicare Advantage and Medigap commissions that I think is less talked about in the report… It is mentioned briefly, but it's not mentioned in much detail, is the fact that Medigap insurance companies, often pay cash bonuses for agents selling their plans.
So, we think this is really a bigger conflict of interest than the vacation incentive, since these bonuses can easily become larger than the cost of the vacation itself. Medigap insurance companies, they typically pay these bonuses when they are new to the market. Since they want brokers to start selling their plans, they need people to enroll in them.
The easiest way to do this is to offer brokers more money to try to push a plan. So, these bonuses are often paid when a consumer goes through underwriting. Meaning you must medically qualify for a plan. Remember, in other episodes we talked about how to get a new Medigap plan.
Most companies want as many consumers as possible to go through health questions so they can have the healthiest members possible to keep rates lower for the long term, when it comes to a Medigap plan, and I'm going to throw this back to Joanne to give an example of the bonus program, but before I forget, I don't think I mentioned it.
We will link to the full report by Senator Warren in the show notes of this video. And if you want us to just email you a pdf, just send us an email asking.
Joanne:
So, here is an example of a current bonus program in Michigan, and we're going to link again to examples of the bonus programs for agents in the show notes.
But Medigap Company A, they're offering a $325 bonus per underwritten application. Underwritten means we're asking the health questions or $150 per open enrollment application, which are easier to submit. Now, Company B is offering a $250 bonus per underwritten application and a $25 per open enrollment application.
Remember that these bonuses are paid in addition to the normal commission that we received that we talked about earlier. We just talked about seasoned agents and earning a trip and things like that.
Not the case, in this case, they do write one policy and they are getting these bonuses. So, sometimes that's where I think the conflict can come into play.
Cameron:
Because, yeah, as a new agent, it's much easier to get a couple bonuses for applications than it is to sell hundreds of plans to get a vacation. So, the bonuses are much more of a perverse incentive than the trips.
Joanne:
Exactly. And if you think that enrolling in a Medicare Advantage plan means your broker doesn't get a bonus, that's now also not true. So, these ones aren't as advertised as bonus. It's a little more complex. But with most Medicare Advantage plans, brokers get what are called “overrides”.
They work just like a bonus does. These payments can easily be $150 per Medicare Advantage application. So, if you think that the broker's maximum Medicare Advantage Commission is $601 per year, remember that is set by CMS and we talked about that earlier. You might be surprised to learn that they're earning $601 plus the $150 for a total of now $751.
So, there's a lot of little layers working behind the scenes that you're not seeing.
Cameron:
Override, bonus, whatever you call it. Both Medicare Advantage and Medigap policies have backend incentive structures or bonuses that give agents more money than you probably think as a consumer. So again, the whole point of this is just to shed some light on it so you can kind of understand what's going on behind the scenes.
And bottom-line incentives should not influence a good broker. Having you as a client long term with coverage you are happy with its way more valuable than any trip to Aruba or a bonus for an application. Greedy brokers, they certainly exist, so if you are worried about incentives influencing what plans are presented to you.
Make sure you ask your broker if there are any bonuses associated with the plan that they're offering, and more importantly, just ask them why are they recommending the plan for you overall? If they won't answer you or you feel hesitant to work with them, just compare them to another broker.
So, keep in mind that if a plan is right for you, yeah, we might still get a bonus, but if the plan is right for you based on your needs and you agree with that, sometimes we can't help it. Those bonuses and incentives are built in, so if we say, yes, we are getting a bonus, but you also agree it's the right plan, then it's really a win-win in that case.
And as always, please leave us a review on your podcast app and subscribe so you can listen to future episodes. You can also find more Medicare content from us by going to YouTube and searching Giardini Medicare. Lastly, if you want to send us any feedback or questions, you can send an email to info@gmedicareteam.com.
Thank you, and have a great day.