Joanne (00:00):
Are Medicare supplement plan's not worth it anymore? Should you just enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan instead? We're going to answer some of those questions and more in today's episode.
Cameron (00:07):
But as always, before we start, my name is Cameron Giardini and together with my co-host Joanne Giardini Russell, we operate Giardini Medicare, which is an independent insurance agency based out of Southeast Michigan. Although we were based in Michigan, we do work virtually over the phone to directly help consumers in about 13 states to find the right Medicare coverage for them. If we do not work in your state, we will connect you with another trusted independent agent that will be able to help you find the coverage that you want. And of course, even if you choose not to work with us, we know that the information in today's podcast will help you with a successful and stress-free transition to Medicare. So, a quick overview, we're going to talk about what are Medicare supplements. We will talk about the negatives of Medicare supplement plans. We will talk about how to overcome some of these negatives and lastly, we will mention who are Medicare supplement plans, right or potentially wrong for.
Joanne (00:57):
So, what are Medicare supplements? When we talk about Medicare supplements, we also refer to these plans as “Medigap” plans and they are the same thing. Medicare supplements are sold by private insurance companies, and they're designed to fill the gaps left by Original Medicare. They will cover most of the 20% cost sharing, which is not covered by original Medicare. Again, filling the gaps, thus being called Medigap. These plans will allow policyholders to see any provider that accepts original Medicare, and they rarely will ever require prior authorization. Medigap plans have a higher monthly premium, but typically lower potential out-of-pocket medical costs compared to Medicare Advantage plans. They do not usually provide extra benefits which are not covered by original Medicare, such as routine dental vision hearing, and more. Medigap plans are also standardized by their plan letters and the plan letters range currently from A through N.
(01:47)
You can take a look at page 76 in the Medicare and You handbook to see a good chart with all of the standardized benefits based on the Medigap plan letter. We're also going to link that chart in the show notes. Medigap plan G and Plan N are the most popular plan, so make sure you do listen to our specific episode about those two plans for more details and to learn more about Medigap plans. You can also click the link in the show notes to see that the official choosing a Medigap policy guidebook published by Medicare that is posted below, or just Google choosing a Medigap policy pdf.
Cameron (02:19):
What are the downsides of Medigap plans? Medicare supplement plans are not perfect and they are certainly not for everybody. And we say that even as an insurance agency that has sold thousands of Medigap policies throughout the years. Some of the negatives for Medigap plans are the policies only must cover services that are covered by Original Medicare. And again, that's part A and part B services. It does not cover routine physicals and extra benefits like routine dental vision, hearing over-the-counter transportation, and whatever you see on tv being advertised. There may be some Medigap companies that are exceptions to this, but this going to apply to a very large majority of plans. Also, Medigap plans have higher premiums than Medicare Advantage plans and premiums will continue to rise while you are in the plan over time.
(03:10)
There is no escaping rising premium costs with Medigap plans so make sure you understand that going into it. Prescription coverage with Medigap plans is also separate, so you would need to purchase a separate Part D plan with a separate added monthly premium. Part D coverage also is typically not as good as prescription coverage provided by Medicare Advantage plans due to slightly higher deductibles and potentially higher copays. It's not always that way, but it often is. So, we just want you to be aware of it. Also, you may not be able to change to a different Medigap policy in the future. So, keep that in mind. But of course, we're not just going to talk about the negatives. We're going to talk about what you can do to counteract some of the negatives of Medigap plans. And of course, Joanne can talk about them.
Joanne (03:52):
The first negative Cameron mentioned is that it's only going to cover procedures that are approved by original Medicare. So how do you get around that? Well, understand that a physical won't be covered and an annual wellness visit is covered instead. But there are even some Medigap companies that will provide additional coverage for routine physicals. Consider those if that's an absolute deal breaker for you.
Cameron (04:13):
Yeah, not many companies, but they do exist.
Joanne (04:15):
Although Medigap plans are standardized, it doesn't mean that all plans are the same. Although they must have the same basic benefits because they are standardized, there are Medicap insurance companies that choose to include extra coverage in their plans such as a gym membership, maybe a dental vision hearing add-on, a nursing hotline, and other things like that. Again, not all of them, but some do. So, make sure when you're shopping, you're asking the right questions about those. If you're concerned about having a Medigap plan that doesn't cover dental vision, or hearing kind of services that are routine to Medicare Advantage, for example, you can purchase a separate dental vision and hearing plan. So just because that plan, your Medigap plan might not include that, it doesn't mean you can't purchase a standalone one for those services. We do have an episode, a podcast episode about dental options and that really goes through the details on how you can obtain dental coverage
Cameron (05:06):
Yeah, just because your Medigap policy doesn't cover dental doesn't mean you'll never have dental coverage. I think that's what some people kind of misunderstand. A couple more negatives we'll talk about and what you can do about them is the higher premiums than Medicare Advantage plans and the fact that the Medigap premiums do increase throughout the lifetime of your policy. Understand this is simply a tradeoff for having stronger medical coverage with less out-of-pocket potential cost compared to Medicare Advantage plans. So, if your friend says, “I pay nothing for my Medicare advantage”, and you wonder “why do I have Medigap? Why am I paying more for this?” It's because you probably have better medical coverage. Medigap plans, typically only have you pay a couple of hundred dollars out of pocket for medical costs per year.
Joanne (05:52)
While Medicare Advantage plans, on the other hand, may have you pay a few to several thousands of dollars out of pocket for potential medical costs if you do need them. With that, don't just enroll in the cheapest Medigap plan to try to save the most on premiums. The cheapest plan now is unlikely to be the cheapest plan long term. That's where thinking about those increasing premiums over time comes into play. Just because plans are standardized, it doesn't mean you just pick the cheapest plan and just go with that for the lifetime of the policy. And that's really where brokers like ourselves come into play. We look at overall stability as well as the initial price that you're paying for the plan to figure out what might be good long-term. And then another negative we talked about is the separate Part D prescription coverage.
Cameron (06:34)
This can be somewhat of a positive, it depends on how you think about it, but the first thing does not just pick a Part D plan that matches your Medigap insurance company. If you get a plan from Company X, if they also offer drug coverage or Part D, don't just enroll in their Part D plan without checking the coverage. Make sure that you work with a broker or run your medications through medicare.gov so you can see which Part D plans have the lowest overall cost for your specific prescriptions. This will help you compare dozens of companies, so you're not just stuck with the one that you got the Medigap plan with. Also, I had mentioned separate Part D coverage can even be a benefit since you can change your Part D coverage every year during the fall annual election period without making you change your Medigap coverage. If you love your Medigap plan, you can continue to change your drug coverage without impacting your medical coverage. And now I'll flip it back to Joanne. She can talk about a couple of other negatives with Medigap plans and what you can do about them.
Joanne (07:27):
One of the negatives that Cameron mentioned is that you may not be able to change your Medigap plan in the future. So, it is really, important to understand the concept of your Medigap open enrollment period. This is a period of time; it lasts for six months, and it begins on the first day of the month that you are both age 65 or older and also enrolled in Medicare Part B first time. What this means is that you can purchase any Medigap plan that you are eligible for with no health questions being asked of you. You also cannot be charged more based on any health issues that you might have. In most situations, you will have to qualify for a new Medigap plan based on your health and you can be denied or charged more for coverage with a new plan or a new company.
Joanne (08:09):
So, how do you avoid that? You must know it exists. That's it. You just have to know that this is A potential feature of Medigap plans. Take your time, in the beginning, to choose the right coverage right out the gate when you first start part B, so that it's not going to be a shock to you later. Also, use a broker to compare the dozens of Medigap companies that are available in your state. Ask them about your state-specific rules about changing to another Medigap plan in the future. Then consider all of the Medigap plan options when you're first eligible. Don't just fixate on a Plan G. Plan G, by far, today is the most popular, but we have seen this shift over the years. Five years ago, it was Plan F, now it's becoming plan G. Five years from now, it'll probably be a different plan letter, but at least if you can't change in the future, you're going to know that you did all you did at the time when you first enrolled.
Cameron (08:52):
Yeah, exactly. There are so many options out there when it comes to Medigap plans. I just ran the numbers a couple of weeks ago and I believe in metro Detroit where we're located, there were about 45 different Medigap plans. So, that's 45 insurance companies offering Medigap policies, which is just crazy. So, you really must take the time to compare it. You can't call all of them individually. We can easily compare all of them at the same time. It's just much easier to use an independent broker that can look at them.
Joanne (09:17):
Yeah. And those 45 carriers are not one iota, equivalent to one another at all, right?
Cameron (09:23):
No, no, no. The prices can change. Everything about them is different.
Cameron (09:27):
Price and strength and stability, a whole bunch of things. And that's where the brokers are important so you can see things you aren’t going to see on the surface.
Cameron (09:33):
Yeah, exactly. So now to get away from the negatives of Medigap plans, there's got to be some pros. So, we'll talk positives. You can see any provider that accepts original Medicare across the country. If you have a Medigap policy now they still must agree to treat you. Not every provider is taking new patients, but if they are taking new patients and they are willing to see you, then of course you can see them with a Medigap policy. Doesn't matter which company you have; you have free reign to do that across the country. You also have low medical out-of-pocket costs that we already mentioned. The most popular plan, which is Plan G has a deductible of $226 for 2023. Also, prior authorization. That is more common in Medicare Advantage plans and is very, very rarely needed before procedures with original Medicare and Medigap. Keep in mind that Medicare and your Medigap will still typically only cover medically necessary procedures.
Cameron (10:22):
So just because you don't have prior authorization most times it does not mean it's free for all to get any service done that you want just because you want it. Your doctor still has to make sure it's medically necessary (so no cosmetic surgery). Not if they can justify it somehow. Medigap plans are guaranteed to renew for as long as you continue to pay your premiums. This can help with long-term peace of mind since they are not yearly contracts like Medicare Advantage plans. If you keep paying for your plan, it will stay in place as long as that company exists. Premium increases are based on all individuals enrolled in your Medigap plan with that company, which is important to remember. A lot of people think, okay, well I have cancer, I'm unhealthy, I go to the doctor a lot, are they going to target me to raise my premiums? And the answer is no. They will not raise your premiums as an individual based on just your claims. They are going to look at everybody on the plan and adjust their premiums accordingly. They won't single you out just because you might have more medical issues than others. So now Joanne, you can talk about who Medigap plans could potentially be right for,
Joanne (11:24):
Well, they can be very right for some of these types of folks… Snowbirds. Those people that might travel often and they really value being able to see original Medicare providers anywhere they go in the country. Remember, you go to any Medicare-accepting doctor hospital facility in the country that takes original Medicare. It's a great plan for those people that want to limit any prior authorization worries. They rarely have it, so you really don't have to think about that kind of thing. Also, these plans are great for people with large medical expenses, especially when you know that when you are turning 65 or starting your Medicare, if you know you have preexisting conditions already that is a peace of mind factor knowing you have a set monthly limit in terms of your bills and it does protect against the longer term medical expenses in the future because you can always keep that plan.
Joanne (12:10):
It's right for those people that can afford the monthly premiums. We always tell people that part of getting a Medicare supplement is you must be okay with paying premiums. I love how Cameron says sometimes that with every plan you choose with Medicare, you're going to have to sacrifice something. So, with a Medicare supplement, it's fantastic coverage, but you're going to sacrifice potential dollars. If you're healthy and you're paying $125 a month, you might not be happy 18 months later because you're paying for what you consider a wasted premium. Again, compared to Medicare Advantage with zero premium, that's what you're going to kind of look at. You must value the insurance and be okay with paying a higher premium. If you don't set a high priority on extra benefits such as dental and vision, over-the-counter, companion care, groceries, transportation, and all the things that you're seeing on the TV commercials, if that doesn't really fire you up to get a Medicare advantage plan, then a Medicare supplement could be right for you.
Cameron (12:59):
Yeah, definitely. And we've already mentioned that Medigap plans are certainly not right for everybody. We would never say that, but now I will talk about who they could be potentially wrong for. If you're okay with networks, prior authorization, and potentially higher out-of-pocket costs medically, but you want low premiums and you want those extra benefits, maybe a Medigap policy's not right for you and you might want to consider Medicare Advantage. Also, if you're somebody with Medicaid that pays your out-of-pocket healthcare expenses, you certainly should not get a Medigap plan. Or, in 99.9% of those cases. For those with certain retiree coverages like TRICARE for life, which is for veterans that retired from the military, and other retiree coverages, you may not want Medigap plans because those policies are a good replacement for it. Also, if you are very concerned with extra benefits like Joanne mentioned, then you certainly might want to consider Medicare Advantage.
Cameron (13:49)
Also, if you cannot qualify for a Medigap policy based on your health, then you really don't have many options in that case. So, Joanne already mentioned that your Medigap Open Enrollment when you first start Part B is the only time for the most part that you're really guaranteed coverage with a Medigap policy. So, if you find that you have a Medicare Advantage and you want to change to Medigap and you simply can't do it, you might have to stay with Medicare Advantage at that point. Lastly, those that cannot afford higher monthly premiums for Medigap policies certainly will want to consider Medicare Advantage coverage. This is especially true for people under age 65 on Medicare due to disability and other factors. All right, so Joanne, are Medigap plans bad?
Joanne (14:30):
No, of course not, but they're not for everybody, right? Anyone that's saying to you that Medicare Supplements are the one size fits all option is simply wrong. You must think about your long-term coverage, and what is right for you over the next 10 to 20 years versus just looking at your first year on Medicare. Always remember that the best time to purchase a Medigap policy, if it is what you want, is during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period. Remember, that's the six months when you're just starting out with part B coverage. Even if you don't purchase one of these plans, at least take the time to consider it. Go listen to our previous in-depth Medigap podcast episode if you want more details about what Medigap coverage looks like. Again, this is just discussing the downside of Medicare supplements today.
Cameron (15:07):
And just to go back quickly to the not one size fits all thing when it comes to Medicare supplements, if you scroll social media or especially YouTube where we also have videos, you'll see a lot of videos that say, “why I would never get Medicare Advantage”, “why I would only do Medicare supplements”. Well, they don't speak for everybody. More people enrolled in Medicare Advantage versus Medicare supplements. So, I'm not saying you should go that route, but there's clearly something there and there is clearly a reason that both options exist. Take the time to compare both, and at the end of the day, the only bad Medicare coverage options are ones that you did not choose based on your specific health needs and circumstances. Medicare plans are just one of the two main options when it comes to Medicare coverage. So of course, tune into our other episodes and look at more information about Medicare Advantage plans versus Medicare supplements. As always, please leave us a review on your podcast app and subscribe so you can listen to future episodes. You can also find more Medicare content from us by going to YouTube and searching Giardini Medicare. Lastly, you can send us any feedback or questions by sending an email to info@gmedicareteam.com. Thanks for listening and have a good day.